POLL: Perry Minasian Trade Deadline Grade

[Angels 1961]

21 minutes ago, ThisismineScios said:

Also…he wasn’t actually that good. Not sure if people on AW actually watch the games or not. 

No, he wasn't, and I hope halos stay away from him this off season.

[floplag]

it doesnt matter, he didnt make the decisions... 

[aznhockeyguy]

Noah was league average being paid 21 million, that's a negative in my book.  It was an interesting gamble by Perry. 

[tomsred]

Does losing McKinnon to the A's lower Minasian's grade?  It's a direct result of the process.

[eligrba]

5 hours ago, tomsred said:

Does losing McKinnon to the A's lower Minasian's grade?  It's a direct result of the process.

I think he is simply continuing to fail.

[Stradling]

On 8/4/2022 at 6:45 PM, TroutCron said:

Two weeks of ST is hardly enough of a sample size. He has had other opportunities and failed. Right now he is hitting .120

I have no idea if he will be any good but before we acquired him he had about 100 at bats which is about a months worth of at bats over the course of three years. Too premature to call him a bust. 

[Stradling]

21 hours ago, floplag said:

it doesnt matter, he didnt make the decisions... 

of course he did. 

[totdprods]

MacKinnon is exactly the type of player that Oakland or Tampa will figure out how to use perfectly. 

[ukyah]

the marsh trade, which was relatively unexpected, was a good trade for a rebuilding team. unfortunately, the angels don't know how to rebuild. so we'll see how that works out.

the iglesias trade was good to offload the money, but my feelings go all the way back to last year's trade deadline where they mismanaged that spectacularly.

the rest were treading water trades. they relieved cash and brought back nobody likely to really change the roster going forward.

it's just more of the same.

 

grade: C.