OC Register: Hoornstra: MLB’s unbalanced schedule favors fans, but not the planet

[AngelsWin.com]

Major League Baseball made a giant break from tradition last week with the announcement of its 2023 regular-season schedule. No longer will team travel be bound by the antiquated notions of the American and National League circuits. All 30 teams will play each other, giving fans in each city a chance to see the game’s biggest stars in person.

To one former major leaguer, “breaking from tradition” and “forward-thinking” aren’t necessarily the same.

Chris Dickerson spent parts of seven seasons (2008-14) in the majors with the Cincinnati Reds, Milwaukee Brewers, New York Yankees, Baltimore Orioles and then-Cleveland Indians. The Los Angeles native and former Sherman Oaks High School standout retired after the 2017 season and plunged full-time into his other passion: cleaning up the planet.

Dickerson co-founded Players For The Planet in 2008. A 501(c)(3) nonprofit, the stated goal of PFTP is “focused on bringing professional athletes together to help inspire communities to build awareness of the power we have to reverse the environmental crisis.”

When Dickerson is not raising awareness of his organization, or fundraising, you might find him at the beach. He rallied several retired big leaguers (Kenny Lofton, Ryan Braun, and Jerry Hairston Jr., were among those on the guest list) to join PFTP volunteers in a cleanup at Santa Monica Pier in July in conjunction with the All-Star Game. Four years ago, a video of garbage washing ashore in the Dominican Republic went viral. PFTP gathered 75 volunteers to clean up the beaches at Montesinos and Fort San Gil, removing 416 pounds of debris in the process. Dominican natives Nelson Cruz and Amed Rosario joined in the cause.

“When I got into pro sports, seeing the amount of stuff we consume, particularly with plastic, that was something I wanted to address when I was still in Triple-A,” Dickerson said. “The response was tremendous. That’s really how I got started.”

Progress has been incremental. Rallying players to the cause has been a success, Dickerson said. Forward-thinking initiatives at the team level are becoming less uncommon. The Seattle Mariners claimed to stage an entirely carbon-neutral game in 2015 through carbon offsets, renewable energy credits and water restoration certificates. In March, the Boston Red Sox announced they would purchase enough carbon offsets to turn Fenway Park into the majors’ first carbon-neutral facility.

At the league level, there is still much work to be done.

This brings us to the 2023 schedule.

Only a particular stripe of misanthrope asks, “sure, fans in St. Louis can see Mike Trout and Shohei Ohtani next year, but at what cost to the environment?” Answering that question raises the bar further, but I’ll bite. We can approximate the number of miles teams will add to their travel schedule under the new format next year.

Take the Angels. This season, they will play 10 games each in Oakland and Arlington, Texas, and nine each in Seattle and Houston. Next season, the Angels will play just five games in Oakland, six in Seattle, and seven each in Arlington and Houston. They are losing 13 intradivisional road games while adding trips to Atlanta, Philadelphia, Queens, and St. Louis.

Houston, the most remote city on the AL West itinerary, is 1,353 miles from Anaheim as the crow flies. St. Louis, the closest out-of-division road game against an NL team, is 1,577 miles from Anaheim. MLB’s schedule-makers can reduce the impact of these added distances by lumping the new Eastern road games together, but the bottom line is clear: across the league teams will be flying more, not less, in 2023.

Climate researcher Seth Wynes found that the NBA, NHL and MLB collectively reduced their carbon footprint by 22% per game during their COVID-shortened 2020 seasons – when smaller traveling parties and reduced travel distances became standard. An unbalanced schedule effectively ignores that lesson. It’s a backward-thinking move.

“Looking at stadium operations, particularly with travel, there has to be greater oversight over changes that can be made to not only promote but really make a significant move toward lessening the impact,” Dickerson said.

Via email, an MLB spokesperson highlighted several team-level initiatives: 22 clubs practice e-waste recycling, and 22 have installed LED field lighting. Nineteen clubs operate food donation programs. A dozen ballparks utilize on-site gardens, 10 utilize solar power, 10 feature electric vehicle charging stations, seven have permanently eliminated plastic straws, and six are LEED certified.

On a more macro scale, MLB says its updated television schedule reduced energy consumption by 328 hours during the offseason. And in Susanville, California, the league announced a post-All-Star contribution to One Tree Planted that will lead to 5,000 trees planted as part of “appropriate reforestation projects.”

But Dickerson is skeptical of any initiative that proposes to “off-set” the net negative behaviors by undertaking smaller net positives.

Dickerson has heard similar refrains in the past.

Related Articles

• MLB |
  Another injury for the Chicago White Sox: Longtime groundskeeper Roger ‘The Sodfather’ Bossard to have hernia surgery
• MLB |
  ‘I want to see him back as soon as possible’: Chicago White Sox manager Tony La Russa is out indefinitely and will undergo more testing
• MLB |
  By adding Gunnar Henderson and other reinforcements, Orioles give playoff push a chance | ANALYSIS
• MLB |
  Shohei Ohtani adds to Yankees August misery with 3-run blast off Gerrit Cole
• MLB |
  With Tony La Russa on his mind, Lance Lynn stops the Chicago White Sox losing streak at 5 vs. the Kansas City Royals

“This is where you get into the weird jargon, and the weird oversight that we’re having with carbon off-sets,” he said. “These large Fortune 500 companies – particularly ones that have a huge carbon footprint – allowing this new phrase of ‘off-setting’ to basically go unchecked … as an excuse to where they can just do whatever they do, go over their emissions goals, and then just say ‘we’re going to plant some trees.’ … That’s not the safety net we need.”

Dickerson said he is planning to meet with MLB deputy commissioner Dan Halem next month to suggest specific initiatives the league can undertake. Dickerson proposed neutral-site playoff rounds, like those staged in 2020, to reduce October travel. Writing in Scientific American, Wynes suggested dropping overseas exhibition games, shortening the regular season, and chartering smaller team aircraft. On Wednesday, the league officially announced the San Francisco Giants and San Diego Padres will play a regular-season game in Mexico City next year.

My suggestion? Abolish the American and National leagues entirely. Put half the teams in the Western Conference, the other half in the Eastern Conference. Or go to a three-league (West, Central, East) format. Some traditional rivalries might be weakened in the process, but un-balancing the schedules would further that aim – and reduce MLB’s carbon footprint.

At some point, the future of the planet ought to outweigh the history of the game. I think that point has arrived.

View the full article

[Dtwncbad]

[Taylor]

I'm predicting some rational, fact-based discussion in this thread.

[DCAngelsFan]

Kudos to Hoornstra, I guess.  I could stop reading after a couple of paragraphs, while he had to stay awake to the end.

Guy flies to the DR to pick up trash (instead of sending $10 to have a local do it?)  

 

Is "performative nonsense" too harsh?  Betcha he makes a decent living with this ..

 

 

Edited September 1, 2022 by DCAngelsFan
Damn spellcheck

[Dtwncbad]

17 minutes ago, Taylor said:

I'm predicting some rational, fact-based discussion in this thread.

You mean like every “scientific model” that shows the world is coming to an end is deeply flawed, usually contrived and biased, and driven by the desires of politicians (and certain industries) to exploit peoples fears for power and money?

[Hubs]

I am a liberal and an environmentalist but this article is just plain stupid. The AL West is the largest geographical division in baseball, and intradivision games are in different time zones. Maybe from a standpoint of the New York Yankees or Detroit Tigers, whose longest division trips are a 3 hour jaunt to Florida and a 2 hour flight to Kansas City?

But when Seattle and Houston are in your division, you can fly three hours to Seattle and then 4.5 hours to Houston on the same trip. The solution is to do more geographical trips.

The solution is to realign the divisions, yes, by expanding to 32, and cutting divisions to 4 teams. 

The Rangers and Astros should be split into two leagues, but they should be in divisions with the Braves, the new Nashville team, the Royals, The Rockies, etc.

NL WEST - Dodgers, Giants, Padres, New Portland Team

AL WEST - Angels, A's, Diamondbacks, Mariners

NL NORTH - Cubs, Brewers, Reds, Cardinals

AL NORTH - White Sox, Twins, Tigers, Indians

NL SOUTH - Braves, Astros, Marlins, Rockies

AL SOUTH - Nashville Team, Rangers, Rays, Royals

NL EAST - Mets, Phillies, Nationals, Pirates

AL EAST - Yankees, Red Sox, Orioles, Blue Jays

[ten ocho recon scout]

1 hour ago, DCAngelsFan said:

 

Guy flies to the DR to pick up trash (instead of sending $10 to have a local do it?)  

 

 

That's actually funny, and a great point.

[Blarg]

3 hours ago, Hubs said:

I am a liberal and an environmentalist but this article is just plain stupid. The AL West is the largest geographical division in baseball, and intradivision games are in different time zones. Maybe from a standpoint of the New York Yankees or Detroit Tigers, whose longest division trips are a 3 hour jaunt to Florida and a 2 hour flight to Kansas City?

But when Seattle and Houston are in your division, you can fly three hours to Seattle and then 4.5 hours to Houston on the same trip. The solution is to do more geographical trips.

The solution is to realign the divisions, yes, by expanding to 32, and cutting divisions to 4 teams. 

The Rangers and Astros should be split into two leagues, but they should be in divisions with the Braves, the new Nashville team, the Royals, The Rockies, etc.

NL WEST - Dodgers, Giants, Padres, New Portland Team

AL WEST - Angels, A's, Diamondbacks, Mariners

NL NORTH - Cubs, Brewers, Reds, Cardinals

AL NORTH - White Sox, Twins, Tigers, Indians

NL SOUTH - Braves, Astros, Marlins, Rockies

AL SOUTH - Nashville Team, Rangers, Rays, Royals

NL EAST - Mets, Phillies, Nationals, Pirates

AL EAST - Yankees, Red Sox, Orioles, Blue Jays

Adding more teams just creates a larger carbon footprint. 

[Stradling]

Fuck the earth

[Taylor]

30 minutes ago, Stradling said:

Fuck the earth

We'll just find a new planet anyway like in the movies.

[Angels 1961]

Look again at the blue dot. That's us everyone we know, have heard of every human being who ever was lived out their lives. The Earth is where we make our stand. I for one think it's too late and damage done is only going to get worse. Man is doing an experiment, took hundreds of million years to form fossil fuels. Man wants to burn them up in 200 years

[Second Base]

[ten ocho recon scout]

7 hours ago, Taylor said:

We'll just find a new planet anyway like in the movies.

But then we'll figure out at the end that it's still earth, and those damn apes ruined it.

[Second Base]

7 hours ago, ten ocho recon scout said:

But then we'll figure out at the end that it's still earth, and those damn apes ruined it.

Yeah but I bet they were pretty awesome at baseball. 

[Jason]

15 hours ago, Stradling said:

Fuck the earth

That’s what the aliens planning to evade have probably said 

[Dtwncbad]

A recent study by environmental professors at UC Berkeley funded by a State grant has concluded that the gross volume of wood used for bats by professional baseball over the last 140 years is equal to the amount of wood necessary to build enough bats for approximately 140 years of professional baseball games.

Don’t worry, state representatives are feverishly working on a “pay your fair share” taxation policy to address this.

[notherhalo]

19 hours ago, Stradling said:

Fuck the earth

I always hated Captain Planet cartoon

 

thinking because I was a child they could slip propaganda in a cartoon and I would take it without noticing

The bad guy who flew around polluting the earth was always my hero

[AngelsLakersFan]

The mind virus is real

[CaliAngel]

Don't worry, electric cars are going to fix everything. 

Nevermind all the celebrities using their private jets every other day to grab lunch halfway across the country. 

[Tank]

[Dtwncbad]

43 minutes ago, CaliAngel said:

Don't worry, electric cars are going to fix everything. 

Nevermind all the celebrities using their private jets every other day to grab lunch halfway across the country. 

[Taylor]

So are Teslas exempt from the newfound EV scorn?

[ten ocho recon scout]

8 hours ago, Jason said:

That’s what the aliens planning to evade have probably said 

"What happened? You guys were supposed to take over that planet!?" - Alien president

 

"Sir.... trust us...." - Alien who scoped earth out, then came home.

[Taylor]

4 minutes ago, ten ocho recon scout said:

"What happened? You guys were supposed to take over that planet!?" - Alien president

 

"Sir.... trust us...." - Alien who scoped earth out, then came home.

Yeah, my favorite theory to explain why we haven't encountered extra terrestrials despite the universe being so big, is that some alien race found us and observed us from afar, then pulled a Grandpa Simpson.

[Jason]

1 minute ago, Taylor said:

Yeah, my favorite theory to explain why we haven't encountered extra terrestrials despite the universe being so big, is that some alien race found us and observed us from afar, then pulled a Grandpa Simpson.

I’m in the camp the travel inter dimensionally so it’s rather easy to avoid us when necessary