Starting Rotation

[Hubs]

Now that the 1-5 has had at least three starts, (not including Canning and Davidson) who should really be in the rotation?

From Baseball-Reference.com

Name                       Age W L  W-L%  ERA GSV    IP   H  R ER HR BB  SO ERA+  FIP  WHIP
Shohei Ohtani            28 2 0 1.000 0.86   4  21.0   6  2  2  0 13  27  531 3.03 0.905
Reid Detmers*           23 0 1  .000 4.50   3  16.0  15 10  8  2  6  19  102 4.06 1.313
Patrick Sandoval*     26 1 0 1.000 1.23   3  14.2  11  4  2  1  6  10  374 4.06 1.159
Tyler Anderson*        33 1 0 1.000 6.75   3  14.2  19 11 11  5  8  10   68 8.22 1.841
Jose Suarez*             25 0 1  .000 9.26   3  11.2  21 13 12  2  7   7   50 6.14 2.400
Griffin Canning          27 0       0 3.60   1   5.0   5  2  2  0  0   4  133 2.31 1.000
Tucker Davidson*     27 1 1  .500 2.53   0  10.2  10  3  3  0  3   9  183 2.47 1.219
Team Totals               28.0 9 8  .529 3.62  17 149.0 130 71 60 14 59 137  128 4.14 1.268
 

 

 

 

Edited April 19, 2023 by Hubs

[mmc]

Don't really understand the question, the poll includes 2 of the current 6, so shouldn't you be able to select 2 options?  I don't think we are going to change to 5.

[Hubs]

1 minute ago, mmc said:

Don't really understand the question, the poll includes 2 of the current 6, so shouldn't you be able to select 2 options?  I don't think we are going to change to 5.

Fixed, sorry

 

[Revad]

I’d like them to flip flop Suarez and Davidson for the time being.

[mmc]

 

[Angel Oracle]

I vote for Canning to remain as the extra starter, and for Davidson and Suarez to flip flop for now.

Over 10.2 innings, Davidson’s ERA and FIP are similar (2.53 vs 2.47).

Hopefully Bachman and/or Silseth are forcing their hand in another 1-2 months.

Edited April 19, 2023 by Angel Oracle

[Angelsjunky]

They've invested too much money to give up on Anderson after 3 starts. If he's still pitching nerf balls after, say, 10 starts, he might get pushed to bullpen duties.

Suarez, however, is on the hot seat. I imagine that if he doesn't turn it around in the next couple starts, they'll start auditioning minor league guys.

[Angel Oracle]

7 minutes ago, Angelsjunky said:

They've invested too much money to give up on Anderson after 3 starts. If he's still pitching nerf balls after, say, 10 starts, he might get pushed to bullpen duties.

Suarez, however, is on the hot seat. I imagine that if he doesn't turn it around in the next couple starts, they'll start auditioning minor league guys.

My rotation as of now:

Ohtani, Sandoval, Detmers, Anderson, Davidson, and Canning as the extra.

Still too many lefties