1 - So, in my book, he's #3 on this list (which isn't position-specific) - the top two are immaterial cheaters...
2 - His OPS compared to other All Star/HOF SS is ridiculous...
3 - He has an entire portfolio of clutch performances on the biggest stages (ALDS, WS, post-9/11...)
4 - In this era of poor-character-quality athletes, I put a premium on guys that go about their business, act like professionals and don't beat or cheat on their wives, do drugs or take steroids, or act like Jr. High aged children between the lines...
5 - Longevity means something in my book. You don't stick around in this high-priced business unless you add some perceived value by a good number of individuals in coaching and management...
6 - When I think of "icons" of the MLB franchise over my lifetime, I think of guys like Ripken, Schmidt, Brett, Pujols, Jeter, Maddux, Chipper, Pedro... I realize some of that perception is shaped by the media, but there's a lot of commonality among those names (I almost put Molitor and Griffey on that list, but...). Closer to home we have Nolan, Salmon - and Trout someday...
I'm not a Yankee fan, but I don't understand all of the energy expended by Jeter detractors at present. He's one of the greats. He's earned the adulation and retrospect of the past few days...