i'm in no way embarrassed to say that i lost faith in him after 2012. i was a very vocal proponent of his upon his hire, but he struggled pretty hard for two years from the fan perspective. his FA decisions two years in a row were brutal in their outcomes. and a fair portion of that may have been bad luck, but not the majority.
luckily, the behind the scenes FO systems building that he and servais were accomplishing was coming together wonderfully, but that wasn't observable from a fan perspective or in the wins and losses either.
he redeemed himself last year in my eyes, and has finally become the gm i had hoped he was initially. maybe he already was, but now it's observable.