He went out and made Welkie consult with the 1 base umpire and both agreed incorrectly the Aybar was out. So what the **** more is he supposed to do? The argument is a dead in the water, it is not as though he can argue a missinterpretation of the rule. Aybar was ruled out and his appeal source upheld the call. He has to go back to the dugout, to stand his ground out there would be stupid as the call.