Yeah, i see what you are saying. My main concern, as you indicated in your first post, is that a deal for a big time FA could be disastrious. A fivr year deal for one of those guys maybe works out for 2 years and then starts looking like the Sabathia situation.
I really want this team to start for the Giants model of only bringing in mid level FAs (think Hudson), the big money deals need to be reserved for the talent we develop, and not for underperforming mercenaries (giants have spent money, but its on guys like posey and cain).