I listened to the interview with Gurnick. Clearly he's very conflicted. I have always maintained in my argument about the HOF, that it full of liars, cheaters, murders, and so on...
Now it's good to see some of these writers acknowledging that you can't have a huge void in the HOF that covers 20 years, and misses out on the guy with the most Cy Youngs, or the dude who hit the most bombs.
Gurnick should have abstained this year, but wanted to help Morris along.
It's tough to wipe out a 20+ year period off a ballot. He won't vote again. It's too bad.. He's not the villain people make him out to be. But he didn't handle it well.