This is not an all star game. They're not out to start every player that's retiring or sh*t like that. I dislike Melvin greatly but even I can't understand this argument. Dunn could have DH'd and I'm sure would not have done better than Moss, also, Callaspo got a slappy base hit when it counted. Say what you want but not PH'ing Dunn was a smart move by Melvin. Just like not PH'ing Ibanez was a smart move by Yost.