Again, where did I say anyone was incompetent? You are reading too much into the statements I have made. Here is the conversation, as I know it.
Jay suggested that the GM might play an equal part in all this blame.
Then you decided that all the players given to the coaching staff were competent at the time of their arrival.
I merely pointed out that if they were as competent as you suggest, they would have lived up to the expectations of the people who signed them.
At the time of their arrival, the only people with any expectations were the GM and his staff, the players in question, and the handful of people in the know.
I hope this clears up my part in the conversation for you.