That 1/2 game lead is really like holding on to the lifeboat guardrail after the Titanic sinks. Until someone pulls you in your still dead in the water.
The A's commited two errors, the Angels none. The difference in this game was Josh Hamilton being the black hole in the 4th spot of the batting order. Had he come through early in this game the Angels would have blown out the A's.
With that A's bullpen the first home run was the game ender. If you want to beat the A's you have to beat them before they get to the 7th inning, not play catch up.
I am not arguing he should have pulled him after the home run but having him face the righthander Donaldson was not a bad move, his hit was off a good inside fastball that should have jammed him. What I am arguing is the guys yelling he should have pulled him the moment Cespedes walked. You have to trust your power arms for more than one batter.
Everyone screaming to pull him was as knee jerk as any rabble gets. Everyone was screaming to pull CJ in the first inning, the 2nd innings, the 3rd inning..., the rabble reacts to the moment.
He came within inches of getting Cespedes out on strikes. I don't blame Scioscia for leaving him in to face Jaso, you have a lead and Jepsen is your best power arm. After Jepsen is B talent in the bullpen besides Fieri.
Scioscia left Wilson in for 107 pitches after disaster in the 1st. That was the right decision. Basicly it comes down to the guy on the hill performing and not pulling the plug too soon. I thought CJ wasn't making it out of the 2nd and Downs was pulled too soon.
So I was wrong on CJ and maybe right on Downs but who knows if Downs doesn't shit the bed like he has in the past. Who knows if Jepsen gets a called strike 3 on a close pitch to Cespedes or a fly ball out fron the next batter.
Far easier to make those pitching change decisions after the results are in.