First let me say, I'm not on the fire anybody bandwagon. At best it would be extremely difficult if not impossible for any one of us to analyze with surety the effect Butcher is having on the pitching staff without us being involved in day to day operations. Same could be said for the batting or any other coach.
It would seem to me that summarizing Butcher’s overall effectiveness using individual players is silly, but maybe that’s really all a coach can do. Hope he gets a handful of players at any given time to listen to his advice.
One would think that with good coaching and the law of averages coming
together, we would have seen a few reliable arms coming out of the pen since the Scott Shields days. Maybe the fault lies somewhere else, scouting perhaps? It sure seems something isn’t right.
Take a look at the complete list of relief pitchers that have come up through our
system or have little or no major league experience when they joined us.
Of the list of pitchers below (which only covers the last three years), who if any have
gone from serviceable to good? I’m curious to hear why that shouldn’t be a concern.
Rafael Rodriguez
Jordan Walden
Sean O'Sullivan
Brian Stokes
Rich Thompson
Trevor Bell
Matt Palmer
Jason Bulger
Michael Kohn
Bobby Cassevah
Francisco Rodriguez
Horacio Ramirez
David Carpenter
David Pauley
Andrew Taylor
Steve Geltz
Kevin Jepsen
Garrett Richards*
Nick Maronde*
* newbs
The jury is still out on the bottom three, with Jepsen being the one who needs to finally show up on a consistent basis, or not.