Ok I still hate it. But, trying to consider this:
Alvarez - almost certainly the real deal, but giving up a reliever in a trade is hard to really get TOO upset over.
Rondon - good defense at short, yes. Are we sure that the bat is not a little bit of a mirage, though. So far he had a good season in rookie ball (any good prospect does) and is putting up strong stats in A ball, which we continually get told not to overreact to. And as far as speed goes, his 8 SB have come with 6 CS.
Lindsey - our best organizational depth. Questionable defensively, and questionable plate discipline. Real power though (17 HR in that park in AA is no joke).
Rose colored beer goggles?