Everyone just needs to take a deep breath. Are we really throwing out five strong (overall, one as a reliever) seasons due to three bad months? Meanwhile Santiago has never been to the postseason and only got his starting spot back due to injuries, and Shoemaker wasn't on anyone's radar in the entire industry before this season? They have both been briliant the last few months, but I am far more confident in CJ, who has a more proven record, has been to the postseason (with 6 solid starts and 3 bad ones), and won't be intimidated by good hitters (say he is cocky all you want, but I'll take that over some of our past pitchers who would implode when things went badly)?