I chose the time frame the Angels consistenly started winning for a fair argument. If I really wanted to be a douchebag, I'd go from 1968-2012, then there's not even a comparison, the A's trumps anyone not named the yankees. however, for the last 12 seasons - quite possibly the golden age of Angels' baseball - the A's have kept up with them for the most part. The Angels won their only title when they were operating no differently than the A's, and then they started buying players and they haven't reached the WS since. Is that 2002 team better than the let's say the 2008 Angels? I doubt it. It's just that the playoffs are a crapshoot. Especially in the wildcard era. That's why WS titles is irrelevant in this argument. The Angels have 5 divisions titles, the A's have also 5. And that's that.