In 2014 who will prove more valuable

[HaloFan85]

As mt said, it's completely subjective.  Just make it simpler and ask who'll get the higher WAR.

 

If both healthy, I'll say Bourjos.

[arch stanton]

The lone given in this equation is Bourjos' defense, which is the best tool either offer but Calhoun's full season value has a slightly higher ceiling. If Calhoun can be the hitter between Trout and Pujols who can take pitches to allow Trout to run and still get on base while holding down RF then he's got value beyond WAR.

[Angel Oracle]

I am not convinced Calhoun will start.

Who is going to start instead? Shuck?

If so, then Scioscia is truly reaching the clueless state.

[Brent Maguire]

If Shuck gets over 250 PA, I'll be be completely on board with firing Dipoto and Scioscia.

Dude isn't that good.