Is it too late to talk Tim McCarver out of retirement?

[Troll Daddy]

I like some Orel

[Brandon]

Sutcliffe is the worst. I like Reynolds and Hershiser.

Sutcliffe is from a suburb of KC next to my family. When I fly out there we usually bowl and he's at the same bowling alley. Talk about a dude that can handle his booze.

[Brandon]

I don't think it matters. We only hear these guys during the playoffs.

[Docwaukee]

I don't think it matters. We only hear these guys during the playoffs.

nicely done. 

[nando714]

Rooney Rule

[YouthofToday]

I don't think it matters. We only hear these guys during the playoffs.

Underrated post. Well played sir.

[disarcina]

I like Harold Reynolds........think he does a pretty good job..........

 

I think he'd be a good replacement for McCarver..........

 

as for McCarver, he's had a good run, never thought he was the best but did think he's not been as good past several years -- but I think some of the rough criticism of him on the various posts is a little unfair.........

 

still, he's a had a good run, time for someone new...........Reynolds is better than McCarver -- so that's an ungrade/

 

Not sure why some folks don't care for Reynolds.........I liked him as a player and think he does a good job at the sports commentator posts he's held (ESPN, MLB TV etc).

[Kenny]

I like Reynolds, as well.  He's not that bad.  Didn't he have Trout's back for MVP last season?

[RenoHalo]

I love Sutcliffe as a color guy, I'd vote for him or Mark Grace (if he had a DD)...

[Lhalo]

No to Hershiser and Reynolds. Ugh. There has to be a better, more coherent former ballplayer than those two.

It's not personal. Merely a preference in style.

Google why Reynolds left ESPN...

I heard what happened at ESPN was mostly bs, hence he was picked up at MLB Network without much dispute.

[Bruce Nye]

The announcer that impressed me this year was Mark Langston.  He really studies the game - particularly pitchers and had terrific insight during the year.

[nate]

Yeah, Langston got a lot better.

 

A lot of people on here hate Gubi but I actually really appreciate the analysis he gives during games.

[Mark68]

I like Reynolds, as well.  He's not that bad.  Didn't he have Trout's back for MVP last season?

He certainly didn't. He and Bryan Kenny argued about it. His whole argument was, "Triple Crown, hands down".

[yk9001]

Sutcliffe is from a suburb of KC next to my family. When I fly out there we usually bowl and he's at the same bowling alley. Talk about a dude that can handle his booze.

 

 

 

"George Clooney  - He's going over there to solve that thing"

[Brandon]

That's about right.