DH rules question. Fletcher?

[Erstad Grit 2,342]

If Ohtani is DH.

He comes in to pitch and finishes an inning as a reliever.

Pitcher spot comes up to bat, he hits for himself as pitcher since DH is forfeited.

Is all this legal? 

I'll take my answer off the air. 

 

 

[tdawg87 32,773]

I believe so, but I'm not positive.

@Jeff Fletcher

[wopphil 3,547]

Can you even go from DH to a position?

If so, wouldn’t the pitcher just take over the DH spot in the batting order? So if Ohtani finished the inning pitching, and the pitcher/DH spot then came up in the lineup, he would hit just as he would if he never departed the DH spot. But if someone else came into pitch before the pitcher/DH spot came up again, then they would take over that spot. 

[Dtwncbad 3,481]

14 minutes ago, Erstad Grit said:

If Ohtani is DH.

He comes in to pitch and finishes an inning as a reliever.

Pitcher spot comes up to bat, he hits for himself as pitcher since DH is forfeited.

Is all this legal? 

I'll take my answer off the air. 

 

 

Going forward it will all depend on what Gavin Newsome wants to allow or regulate that day.

[Angelsjunky 10,446]

FAKE RULES.

[eligrba 5,116]

Based on how Ohtani hit last year, I think he should have a DH.

[Trendon 356]

4 hours ago, Erstad Grit said:

If Ohtani is DH.

He comes in to pitch and finishes an inning as a reliever.

Pitcher spot comes up to bat, he hits for himself as pitcher since DH is forfeited.

Is all this legal? 

I'll take my answer off the air. 

 

 

It should be legal.

If the DH enters the field, the team forfeits the DH and the pitcher enters the batting order in the DH's place.

[Dochalo 25,602]

I just went through the rules and there is no specific rule designation accounting for the DH coming in to pitch but there are a couple other sub rules that likely account for this scenario.  

Since the DH can only be for a pitcher then once the DH comes in to play defense, the pitcher has to hit.  So as long as Ohtani stayed in as the pitcher, he would get to hit as the pitcher.   

If a player came in from DH to play 1b for instance, then that play would still hit from the DH spot in the lineup but then the pitcher would have to hit in the 1bman's lineup slot.  

so the answer to your question is.....Four?  

[Angels 1961 381]

6 hours ago, Dtwncbad said:

Going forward it will all depend on what Gavin Newsome wants to allow or regulate that day.

I will never concede, but hospitals are filling up and do not have personnel to care for everyone.

[Jeff Fletcher 7,323]

Sorry I hadn’t been checking the board for a while. 
 

But this is correct. If Ohtani goes from DH to pitcher, he stays in the lineup as the pitcher. 

[Erstad Grit 2,342]

23 minutes ago, Jeff Fletcher said:

Sorry I hadn’t been checking the board for a while. 
 

But this is correct. If Ohtani goes from DH to pitcher, he stays in the lineup as the pitcher. 

Thanks!

My thought was if he was DH and available as a late inning relief pitcher Angels could still squeeze another at bat from him and only lose the DH for a few innings.