Your all time line up.....

[Stradling]

Without much thought here is my 2nd team:

1b- Miggy

2b- Sandberg

SS- Jeter

3b- Chipper

LF- Winfield 

CF-Griffey

RF- Gwynn

C- Pudge

DH-Manny

 

Right Hander-Pedro

Left Hander- Randy Johnson

Closer-Wagner

[failos]

Mike Trout

 

[Angelsjunky]

1 hour ago, Stradling said:

How difficult was the decision to go with Frank Thomas over Rickey Henderson?  For me the toughest decision was Rickey over Griffey.  

Yeah, I hear that. I could go either way. Peak Henderson (1980-90ish) was a force to behold, although so was peak Thomas (1991-97). Hmm...not sure about that. Now that I think about it, I'd probably drop Manny and insert Henderson. Anyhow, I'm not sure which of these two teams is better:

 

Team A

RF Henderson

CF Trout

1B Pujols

LF Bonds

DH Thomas

SS A-Rod

3B Boggs

2B Utley

C Pudge

 

Team B

LF Walker

CF Griffey

RF Manny

DH Cabrera

C Piazza

1B Bagwell

3B C Jones

2B Sandberg

SS Ripken

 

I like the first one better, but you can't go wrong with the second.

[Angelsjunky]

Rotation would be: Pedro, Clemens, R Johnson, Kershaw, Verlander, with Scherzer as the sixth man.

That was far easier to pick, especially because I didn't have to pick Curt Schilling to do so.

Edited April 9, 2020 by Angelsjunky

[ELEVEN]

If this is who I've seen play in person...

C Bench

1B Pujols

2B Morgan

SS Ozzie

3B Schmidt

LF Henderson

CF Trout/Mays/Mantle

RF Aaron

DH Bonds

SP Ryan

SP Valenzuela

RP Eckersley

RP Rivera

[Don]

C - Rodriguez

1B - Pujols

2B - Alomar

SS - ARod

3B - Thome (he played there for a couple years)

LF - Vlad (gotta let Ichiro play RF)

CF - Trout

RF - Ichiro

 

SP - Pedro

RP - KRod