Best non HOF roster

[happybat4]

If you could field any team of non HOF players what would it be. I'd have to really thing about some but off the top of my head

1b - Keith Hernandez

2nd - Lou Whitaker (Amazing he was off on first ballot) 

3rd - Graig Nettles

CF - Kenny Lofton

Who do you guys have. Let's not include players who are currently on the ballot. 

[ScottT]

Grich over Whitaker 

[stormngt]

Trout CF

Cabrera 1b

Jeter SS

Bonds RF

Rodriguez 3b

Ramirez LF

Posey C

Pujols DH

Clemmons P

 

Best of my knowledge none of those guys are currently in the HOF!

[Sully151]

Pete Rose.

[happybat4]

1 hour ago, stormngt said:

Trout CF

Cabrera 1b

Jeter SS

Bonds RF

Rodriguez 3b

Ramirez LF

Posey C

Pujols DH

Clemmons P

 

Best of my knowledge none of those guys are currently in the HOF!

I said not currently on mlb ballot. I'm also excluding active players. 

[WeatherWonk]

How could Pete Rose not be at second? 

Or did he end up playing more games at 1st?

[Lou]

3 minutes ago, WeatherWonk said:

How could Pete Rose not be at second? 

Or did he end up playing more games at 1st?

He played more games at 1B, LF and 3B than he did at 2B.

[WeatherWonk]

Ah, another fatal memory error. 

I had his rookie card...........long ago. He came up at 2nd, I believe. Maybe short, with Helms at 2nd.

[Lou]

LF, 3B and 2B were very close. Only 45 games separated the 3 

[stormngt]

1 hour ago, stormngt said:

Trout CF

Cabrera 1b

Jeter SS

Bonds RF

Rodriguez 3b

Ramirez LF

Posey C

Pujols DH

Clemmons P

 

Best of my knowledge none of those guys are currently in the HOF!

My bad.  Just trying to be a smart ass!

[greginpsca]

Fred McGriff