In your opinion the Angels 10 Best Starting pitchers...

[Halofan]

1. Nolan Ryan

2. Chuck Finley

3. Mike Witt

4. Dean Chance

5. Frank Tanana

6. Jared Weaver

7. Clyde Wright

8. Jim Abbott

9. Andy Messersmith

10. Bartolo Colon

 

 

[rageous]

Weaver should be third on that list.

[HaloMagic]

I'd put Blanton around 5th or 6th.

[mtangelsfan]

Ryan, Tanana, Finley, Chance, Wright, Witt, Lackey, Blyleven, Weaver, Messersmith.

[nando714]

Where do you put Bottenfield

[Brandon]

No love for Langston?

 

Good list outside of omitting Omar Olivares

[Broad Street]

I'd have Abbot higher up on the list

[HeavenlyHalos]

1. Nolan Ryan

2. Chuck Finley

3. Mike Witt

4. Dean Chance

5. Frank Tanana

6. Jared Weaver

7. Clyde Wright

8. Jim Abbott

9. Andy Messersmith

10. Bartolo Colon

 

I've never heard of this Jared fellow, but Jered Weaver should be around 3rd or so IMO.

[Broad Street]

Langston and Washburn should both be either on this list or very close to it.

[Inside Pitch]

Nolan

Chuckles

Weaver

Tanana

Lackey

Langston

Witt

Chance

Santana

Escobar

[mtangelsfan]

Langston, Washburn and Abbot are all right there. 

[Second Base]

Can I just say before this gets heated that this is a VERY tough one to answer, we can all agree to that right?

[mtangelsfan]

No!  I am right and anyone who disagrees is wrong.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

and evil.

[tdawg87]

In MY lifetime:

Weaver

Lackey

Finley

Langston

Washburn

Wilson

Abbot

Tripod

Santana

Colon

[tdawg87]

No! I am right and anyone who disagrees is wrong.

and evil.

And probably supports Obama.

[Angel Oracle]

Nolan Ryan

Frank Tanana

Chuck Finley

Jered Weaver

Mike Witt

John Lackey

Mark Langston

Jarrod Washburn

Dean Chance - only because of 1964 season

Bartolo Colon - only because of 2005 Cy Young

Edited May 2, 2014 by Angel Oracle

[ItzTacosYerrp]

Where is Jarrod Weaver??

He has been our ace for a while now!!

[Cdaniel]

What about Sutton?

[Brandon]

Does Jason Dickinson's lone all-star appearance for us in 1997 (maybe '98) not mean anything to you guys!?!

 

Also, Washburn pretty much was average or sucked outside of 2002 with his 18 wins. And who could forget his damn smirk when someone took him deep?

[Stradling]

Nolan

Finley

Weaver

Lackey

Witt

Tanana

Abbott

Langston

Wilson

Adenhart

[tdawg87]

Hey I wasn't planning on going on a feel trip this evening but away we go!

Thanks Stradling!

[open_speed]

Let me fix that for you.

1.8-7 Pitcher #1

2. 8-7 Pitcher #2

3. Nolan Ryan

4. Chuck Finley

5. Mike Witt

6. Dean Chance

7. Frank Tanana

8. Jared Weaver

9. Clyde Wright

10. Jim Abbott

[hats4bats]

I have Ken Hill # 1 based on various historical documents. 

[ten ocho recon scout]

Does Jason Dickinson's lone all-star appearance for us in 1997 (maybe '98) not mean anything to you guys!?!

Also, Washburn pretty much was average or sucked outside of 2002 with his 18 wins. And who could forget his damn smirk when someone took him deep?

thats funny. I have a buddy who used to bring up washburns 'home run smile' all the time.

[Schildog]

Jason Dickson mention!

I remember thinking Brian Anderson would be a perennial all star. I was nowhere near the target with that.