What do you think of this lineup?

[QuinlansMinion]

Calhoun

Aybar

Trout

Pujols

Hamilton

Kendrick
Ibanez

Freese

[NrM]

Why do people still insist on having aybar hit at the top of the order

[arch stanton]

Aybar doesn't need to hit second and I think the rules say your catcher has to bat.

Edited February 21, 2014 by arch stanton

[Stradling]

Yes and a lineup should have nine batters in the AL. Aybar should bat 9th. Pujols will bat 3rd at least one more year.

[Brandon]

Sick lineup

[The Ghost of Bob Starr]

Shark sandwich.

[Spencer]

[laagamer]

Pujols and Hamilton should bat 8th & 9th respectively.

 

Trout should bat 3rd. 

 

Everything else doesn't even matter.

[Marsaka]

Kalhoun

Aybar

Trout

Pujols

Hamilton

Kendrick

Ibanez

Freese

 

i would do: 

 

Trout

Kalhoun

Pujols

Hamilton

Freese

Ibanez

Kendrick

Aybar

Iannetta/Conger

 

perfect righty/lefty lineup.  if pujols hits like he did last year move him down, and let trout take his spot.

[NorCal Halo]

If Trout really would be more productive hitting third, then I would rather see this:

 

L Calhoun

L Hamilton

R Trout

R Pujols

S Ibanez

R Freese

R Kendrick

S Conger

S Aybar

 

However, I still like Marsaka's lineup better.

[QuinlansMinion]

Im sorry guys.  I need to stop posting lineups when im not sober.

[DW711]

Calhoun

Aybar

Trout

Pujols

Hamilton

Kendrick

Ibanez

Freese

 

It'd be about 50-100 runs worse than an ideal line-up.

 

Batting Freese ninth is counter-productive.

[nando714]

Aybar doesn't need to hit second and I think the rules say your catcher has to bat.

I laughed